If they want to make a movie that ignores Alien 3 and Alien: Resurrection, then they should do just that: ignore them. Re-contextualizing the work of other artists in that way is viciously disrespectful.
This is a very disrespectful thing to do. Taking someone else’s work and openly disregarding it is not cool. Not only that, but in any writing course, the first thing they tell you is that it should never be “just a dream.” Saying something is an alternate timeline is one thing, because it acknowledges that your work exists alongside someone else’s work, but to say that, “Oh, that thing I don’t like is not a real thing” is very disrespectful, fan film or not.
Interesting, the writer side of me agrees with Evan and Charles on this one, but the Alien fanboy in me is looking forward to seeing what this film is going to be like. I have found tribute films be like tribute bands. The core audience appreciates them, they are never taken that seriously or commended for their work.
What’s disrespectful is making Alien 3 without a script. What’s disrespectful is killing off Newt making all of Ripley’s efforts in vain. Everyone cheered Ripley when she risked her life to go back and rescue Newt only to find out, oops she died in her sleep on the way home. What a great disservice to the fans making an Alien film without any idea of where they were going. If they couldn’t foresee what to do with Newt they should of figured out another angle. Secondly this is a fan film so they can take any angle they wish and it’s technically but canon. I’m looking forward to it.
The type on this article is too small. The type on your website is too small. i can’t even share it because reading it was visually annoying. good job.
I’d be curious to know what Ridley Scott or Dan O’Bannon think–I would hope they’d get a kick out of the fact that a movie they made and characters they created 36 years ago still resonate. I don’t see these movies as holy writ. They’re studio product. If fat cat producers can do what they will with the characters, why not fans, who have a lot more respect for and emotional connection to the material?